Skip to main content

The Highest Form of Flattery is a Plateau

 It's the most maddening, soul-crushing part of any health journey.

You've done everything "right." You've mastered the rules. You've ditched the inflammatory oils and the hidden starches. You are consistent. You are disciplined. The weight has been falling off... and then, suddenly, it stops.

The scale doesn't budge. For a week. Then two. Then a month.

This is the "Great Plateau." It's the point where most people give up, believing the diet has "stopped working" or that their body is simply "broken."


Having lost and regained over 190 pounds in my life, I am intimately familiar with the plateau. I've hit every single one. And I've learned that a plateau is not a "failure" or a dead end. It's a "checkpoint." It's your body sending you a message, and it's your job to become the "compliance manager" and run an audit to figure out what that message is.

First, let's define a "real" stall. It's not 2-3 days of no change. A real plateau is at least 3-4 weeks with no change in the scale or your body measurements (like your waistline). If you've hit one, don't panic. It's time to run the diagnostic.

Here are the most common culprits, starting with the most likely.


Part 1: The "Carb Creep" Audit

This is, in my experience, the #1 cause of a stall. My clean keto lifestyle is strict: under 20g of net carbs per day. This is the signal that keeps my body in a "fat-burning" state. "Carb Creep" is when those grams sneak back in, unnoticed.

My body is very sensitive. The difference between 15g of carbs and 30g of carbs is the difference between active weight loss and a dead stop.

Where does it creep in? In the "clean" foods.

  • Dairy: Are you adding an extra few spoonfuls of that "clean" Greek yogurt (5-7g carbs) or that full-fat cottage cheese (5-6g carbs)? It adds up.

  • Nuts & Seeds: This is my personal kryptonite. A single handful of "clean" dry-roasted pistachios (9g net carbs) or cashews (10g net carbs) can eat up 50% of my entire day's budget.

  • "Clean Keto" Treats: That Locally Baked Outlet cupcake (2g net carbs) is a fantastic, clean option. But are you having two? Or having one every single day?

  • Sauces & Veggies: Are you using more onions, garlic, or that Coconut Aminos (2g per tbsp) than you used to?

The Fix: The "carb creep" audit is simple. For three days, go back to basics. Be meticulous. Weigh and track everything you eat. Measure that tablespoon of coconut aminos. Weigh that 1/4 cup of nuts. I guarantee you will find the 5-10g of carbs that have crept back into your diet.


Part 2: The "Portion Distortion" Audit

This is the second, equally common culprit. We call it "Calorie Creep."

My OMAD meal is a "powerhouse," but there's a difference between a "powerhouse" and a "caloric bomb." Yes, my "clean" list includes macadamia nuts, olive oil, ghee, and cheese, but these are the most calorie-dense foods on the planet.

As we lose weight and feel better, it's human nature to loosen the reins. That "splash" of olive oil on the salad becomes a "glug." That "slice" of cheese becomes a "chunk." That 1lb steak becomes a 1.5lb steak.


Your body is a machine. If "calories in" (even clean ones) begin to equal "calories out," your weight loss will stop.

The Fix: This is the same fix as the carb audit. For 3-5 days, track your calories and portions. You don't have to do it forever. But you need to run the diagnostic. Get out the food scale. Measure that tablespoon of avocado oil. Re-learn what your 1800-2000 calorie (or whatever your target is) OMAD meal actually looks like.


Part 3: The "New Normal" Audit (Your Body's Response)

This is the most complex, and most "real," reason for a stall. This isn't a "mistake"; it's your body adapting.

You've been successfully losing weight for months. Your "balloons" (fat cells) have shrunk. As I discussed in my post on Leptin, your "fuel gauge" is now sending a different signal. Your body, in its infinite wisdom, is sensing a "famine" and is starting to fight back.

Your body is not "broken"; it is protective. It's establishing a new set point.

This is not a failure! This is your body's "checkpoint." It needs reassurance that the famine is over and that it's safe to let go of the last reserves.

The Fix: This is the most counter-intuitive solution, and it should only be tried after you have confirmed you are not suffering from carb-creep or portion distortion. The fix is to stop trying to lose weight... for a little while.

For 1-2 weeks, intentionally increase your clean calories (add more avocado, more olive oil, more nuts) up to your "maintenance" level. Let your body "settle" at this new weight. This signals to your brain that the "famine" is over, that fuel is plentiful, and that it's safe. It allows your metabolism and hormones to "reset." After 1-2 weeks of maintenance, you can then re-introduce your modest calorie deficit, and you will almost certainly find that the scale begins to move again.


The Takeaway

Weight loss is not a straight, downhill line. It has plateaus. A plateau is not a wall; it's a "level" in the game that requires a new strategy.



Don't give up. Get analytical. Be your own "Compliance Manager." Audit your carbs, audit your portions, and listen to your body's hormonal signals. A plateau is just your body's way of asking you to be more precise.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

"Are you sitting comfortably? Then I'll begin."

"Hello There"  My name is Chris. I'm 53 as I write this in October of 2025, and I'm a gamer, a golfer, and a guy who's been (and continues to be) on a serious health journey. After losing and then gaining over 190 pounds and facing significant cardiac events, I thought I was doing everything right by following a 'keto' diet. I was wrong. I discovered I was eating 'dirty keto'—my 'health foods' were full of inflammatory oils, hidden starches, and artificial sweeteners that were working against me. 'The Path is Too Deep' is my personal blog about ditching the marketing and discovering the power of a Clean, Anti-Inflammatory, Whole-Food Ketogenic Lifestyle. I'll be sharing what I've learned about reading labels, my ongoing journey with weight loss, my strategies for managing mental health (ADHD/dysthymia), and my thoughts on gaming, golf, and technology. It's my personal rulebook for taking back control. "Not all those...

We're In The Endgame Now

In video games, there is usually a clear "End Game." You defeat the final boss, the loot drops, the credits roll, and you put the controller down. You won. In diet culture, we are sold the same fantasy. We are told that if we just "hit our goal weight" - that magical number on the scale - we have crossed the finish line. We imagine a ticker-tape parade where we are handed a trophy that says "Thin Person," and then we go back to "normal." I am here to tell you, from painful, personal experience: There is no finish line. I have "won" the weight loss game before. I lost 190 pounds . I hit the number. I bought the new wardrobe. And then, slowly, silently, and catastrophically, I gained it all back plus interest. Why? Because I treated my health like a project with a deadline, instead of a business with ongoing operations. I thought I was "done." As I rebuild my body at 53, I am not training for a finish line. I am training for the...

Chris v5.3: The Stability Update

In the tech world, there is a concept known as a "System Restore." When a computer becomes bogged down by years of accumulated junk files, corrupted registry entries, and conflicting software, you don't necessarily throw it in the trash. You roll it back. You strip away the bloatware. You wipe the cache. You return the operating system to a point where it actually functioned. I turned 53 this year. In our culture, 53 is often viewed as the beginning of the "End of Life" phase for the "hardware". We are told to expect the proverbial "Blue Screen of Death" at any moment. We are told that the "Dad Bod" is inevitable, that our metabolism has deprecated, and that we should just get comfortable in the recliner and wait for the obsolescence date. "It's too late," they say. "You can't teach an old dog new tricks." I am here to tell you that is a lie . 53 isn't the end of the user manual. It’s just time for a ...