Skip to main content

Over-the-Counter Intelligence

Today, I wanted to share a serious warning. It’s a "gotcha" moment I experienced recently that stopped me in my tracks, and it might just change the way you look at that bottle of "natural" vitamins on your counter.

In my quest to optimize my health, lose weight, and support my cardiac recovery, I did what many of us do: I hit the supplement aisle. I looked for things that promised to boost metabolism, fight inflammation, and support heart health.


I assumed—like most people—that if something is sold over the counter and labeled "natural" or "herbal," it must be safe.

I was wrong.

I discovered that two of the supplements I was taking (or considering) were creating a dangerous, invisible chemical war with the prescription medications keeping me alive.


The "Natural" Trap: My Two Near-Misses

I take a specific cocktail of medications to manage my heart health, including Atorvastatin (Lipitor) for cholesterol and Clopidogrel (Plavix) plus Aspirin as blood thinners.

Here is how my "healthy" supplements almost turned those life-saving drugs into dangerous toxins.

1. The Green Tea "Grapefruit" Effect

I started taking Green Tea Extract because the research is great: it boosts metabolism and fights oxidation. Sounds perfect, right?

The Gotcha: It turns out, Green Tea Extract contains potent compounds that inhibit a specific enzyme in the liver (CYP450). This is the exact same enzyme my body uses to process my Atorvastatin.


By taking the extract, I was essentially shutting down the disposal system for my medication. This could have caused the drug to build up in my bloodstream to toxic levels, leading to severe side effects like muscle breakdown (rhabdomyolysis). It was the exact same danger as drinking grapefruit juice (which I have always avoided), but hidden in a "healthy" green capsule.

2. The Garlic "Stacking" Effect

I also looked into taking concentrated Garlic Oil supplements for their legendary heart-health benefits.

The Gotcha: Garlic is a natural blood thinner (antiplatelet). I am already on two powerful blood thinners (Plavix and Aspirin).

If I had added a high-dose garlic supplement, I would have been "stacking" a third, unregulated blood thinner on top of my prescriptions. This could have thinned my blood to a dangerous degree, putting me at massive risk for internal bleeding or uncontrolled bruising.


The Lesson: Herbs are drugs. Just because they grow in the ground doesn't mean they don't have potent chemical effects. If I hadn't double-checked, I could have landed myself in the ER (again) while trying to get "healthy."


My New Philosophy: Food First, Supplements Second

This warning forced me to completely rewrite my rules for supplementation. I realized I was trying to "pill" my way to health, rather than trusting the food I was eating.

1. The "Whole Food" Shield

Here is the irony: Eating fresh garlic in my stir-fry is perfectly safe. Drinking a cup of brewed green tea is likely fine.

Why? Because nature packages these compounds in reasonable, balanced doses. It is only when we extract, concentrate, and isolate them into a mega-dose pill that they become dangerous "pharmaceuticals."


A clean keto OMAD (one meal a day) - loaded with steak, eggs, broccoli, spinach, and olive oil—is the most powerful multivitamin I can take. It provides nutrients in the form my body recognizes, without the risk of an overdose interaction.

2. Targeted vs. Shotgun Approach

I stopped taking a "shotgun" approach (taking everything that sounds good). I now only take supplements that target a specific, proven need that my diet or geography can't fully meet.

  • Vitamin D: Because I live in Nova Scotia and the sun is scarce.

  • Magnesium: Because our soil is depleted and keto flushes electrolytes.

  • Omega-3s: If I haven't eaten fish that week (I try to eat fish every week).

3. The "Dirty Keto" Supplement Trap

Just like food, supplements are full of fillers. I now audit my pill bottles for the same "red flags" I look for in my grocery cart.

  • Soybean Oil: Common in softgels (Vitamin D, Fish Oil). I look for olive oil or MCT oil bases instead.

  • Sugar/Maltodextrin: Common in gummy vitamins and powders. Hard pass.

  • Titanium Dioxide/Artificial Colors: Unnecessary chemicals used to make pills look pretty.




The Takeaway

If you are on any prescription medication—especially for your heart, blood pressure, or mood (like my Wellbutrin)—you cannot be casual about supplements.

"Natural" does not mean "Neutral."

Before you add a single pill to your routine, do what I did:

  1. Audit your list. Write down everything you take.

  2. Ask the Pro. Take that list to your pharmacist or doctor. They have databases that check for these invisible interactions.

  3. Trust your food. The safest place to get your nutrients is from your plate, not a plastic bottle.

I am still taking supplements, but now I treat them with the same respect—and caution—that I treat my heart medication. Because in the end, my body doesn't know the difference between a drug prescribed by a doctor and a drug I bought at the health food store. It just has to process them all.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Dinner Four-mula

Universal Meal Frameworks I have always found traditional recipes a bit stressful. They often feel like rigid scripts that demand very specific ingredients ("1 tsp of fresh tarragon"), and if you don't have that specific item, it feels like you can't make the dish. If you aren't confident with substitutes, you panic, close the cookbook, and order takeout. I've moved away from cooking with strict recipes. Now, I cook with Frameworks . Think of a framework as a flexible blueprint. It allows you to swap out ingredients based on what you have in the fridge without ruining the meal. When I look at a fridge full of random groceries, I don't see "nothing to eat"—I see possibilities waiting to be slotted into a plan. Here are the 4 Universal Meal Frameworks I use to cook 90% of my meals . Framework 1: The "Skillet Smash" (The Keto Answer to Stir-Fries and Pasta) This is my solution for busy nights. It is fast, uses high heat, and relies on a ...

"Are you sitting comfortably? Then I'll begin."

"Hello There"  My name is Chris. I'm 53 as I write this in October of 2025, and I'm a gamer, a golfer, and a guy who's been (and continues to be) on a serious health journey. After losing and then gaining over 190 pounds and facing significant cardiac events, I thought I was doing everything right by following a 'keto' diet. I was wrong. I discovered I was eating 'dirty keto'—my 'health foods' were full of inflammatory oils, hidden starches, and artificial sweeteners that were working against me. 'The Path is Too Deep' is my personal blog about ditching the marketing and discovering the power of a Clean, Anti-Inflammatory, Whole-Food Ketogenic Lifestyle. I'll be sharing what I've learned about reading labels, my ongoing journey with weight loss, my strategies for managing mental health (ADHD/dysthymia), and my thoughts on gaming, golf, and technology. It's my personal rulebook for taking back control. "Not all those...

We're In The Endgame Now

In video games, there is usually a clear "End Game." You defeat the final boss, the loot drops, the credits roll, and you put the controller down. You won. In diet culture, we are sold the same fantasy. We are told that if we just "hit our goal weight" - that magical number on the scale - we have crossed the finish line. We imagine a ticker-tape parade where we are handed a trophy that says "Thin Person," and then we go back to "normal." I am here to tell you, from painful, personal experience: There is no finish line. I have "won" the weight loss game before. I lost 190 pounds . I hit the number. I bought the new wardrobe. And then, slowly, silently, and catastrophically, I gained it all back plus interest. Why? Because I treated my health like a project with a deadline, instead of a business with ongoing operations. I thought I was "done." As I rebuild my body at 53, I am not training for a finish line. I am training for the...